Cookbook Collecting and Reviews

A Cookbook Village blog written for cookbook collectors and curious cooks. Find out all about collecting cookbooks: used and vintage; reviews and values; recipes and best books to buy for investment.



Cookbook Collecting



RECIPES




TOP CHEF SIGNATURES




COOKBOOK CHECKLISTS




Cookbook Collectibility Reviews



Love and Knishes Jewish Cookbook Review - Collectibility

Love and Knishes Jewish Cookbook cover

I've decided to do my latest collectible cookbook review on a nice vintage cookbook called "Love and Knishes: An Irrepressible Guide to Jewish Cooking." Jewish cookbooks are one of the most popular niche categories of cookbooks at Cookbook Village online store. The book has some nice copy in the introduction chapter from the author advising those who want to know how to become a good Jewish cook to get invited to dinners from a Jewish friend and find out the way things should taste. The information rings true with me as I've tried to replicate some of my mother-in-laws wonderful Jewish dishes.

My mother-in-law makes some memorable Jewish food and I always look forward to the holidays at her house where I know some of the wonderful dishes she has waiting. She usually makes extra portions for me, I have somewhat of an appetite at those festivities. Being Dutch-Indonesian, I grew up on a lot of great cooking, but never got to experience Jewish cooking until I met my wife. I recently went to Passover dinner at Mom's place and wow...my first time eating Charosis. I ate a lot to say the list. Here's how my mother-in-law makes the Love and Knishes Cookbook Charosis Recipe. The original serves 10, my mother-in-law uses more of larger portions for 10. Anyway, now for the collectibility review...

Cookbook Title: Love and Knishes: An Irrepressible Guide to Jewish Cooking Cookbook
Author: Sara Kasdan
Publisher: Vanguard Press, New York
Copyright: 1956
Format: Hardcover (I believe it should have a dust jacket, mine doesn't have one though I'm not sure the first edition came with one or not. There were many printings, including the latest paperback edition from 1996.)
Specialization Categories: Jewish Cookbooks, Vintage Cookbooks
Average Price: $15
Noted Recipes: Potato Knishes, Stuffed Veal Brisket, Matzo Balls, Fried Matzos, Hungarian Almond Torte, Appel Strudel, Charosis (see recipe)

COOKBOOK COLLECTIBILITY RATINGS RATINGS EXPLAINED

Availability: 6.0
Popularity: 2.0
Investment Outlook: 6.0

-------------------------------------
Final Collectibility Factor: 4.67

Love and Knishes Jewish Cookbook - Availability Rating - 6.0
There are many retail book sites that offer the 1996 edition of this book, though the 1956, First Edition is somewhat more difficult to come by. The book is often found with damage and wear, as are most Jewish cookbooks. These cookbooks are made for cooking...although they have become a popular cookbook collecting niche or specialization. I have only come across this cookbook once before, but do see a few 1956 copies available on a few of the online book sites. My copy will be going up for auction soon.

Love and Knishes Jewish Cookbook - Popularity Rating - 2.0
I've given the cookbook a low popularity rating mainly because it is an unknown. This doesn't make it any less interesting. It is a wonderful cookbook with all the classics and many variations on each including knishes, strudels, matzo dishes, herring dishes, and more.

Love and Knishes Jewish Cookbook - Investment Outlook - 6.0
As far as investment goes, this is a definitely a nice cookbook in terms of investment if you collect Jewish cookbooks. Vintage Jewish cookbooks are not very common as not many were published. What you do see a lot of are vintage Jewish community/fundraising cookbooks. This is not one of those books. It is written by a sole author who compiled recipes from Jewish friends and acquaintances.

The book's value is hard to gauge. The newer 1996 copies can be found for around $5, while this 1956 original can go from about $15-$25. The upper end pricing would be applicable to a good condition book--as I mentioned--this is typically difficult to find in the vintage Jewish cookbooks as they are written for use!

Love and Knishes Jewish Cookbook - Final Collectibility Factor Rating - 4.67
While not an overly high final collectibility factor rating, this book is a true find for collectors. As noted above, Jewish cookbooks that were not published by fundraising organizations and synagogue groups were and still are, uncommon. I'd definitely recommend putting a copy of this great little book into your collection. If you specialize in Jewish cookbooks then even better.

Comments

Thank you Mae Travels for contributing to this post. It's good to get a confirmation on what I suspected from my own copy. I haven't had another of these books since this posting. Seems like the pricing is holding steady… which is good. Many books dropped in value in the past year.

One of my readers was unable to post comments due to a browser conflict. The comments have a lot of great information for collectors so I am posting them on his/her behalf. The reader is C.Y./J.E. Cripps. Here is the comment to this Love and Knishes post:Back in June or July you wrote:Love and Knishes Cookbook CoverCookbook Title: Love and Knishes: An Irrepressible Guide to Jewish CookingThe .uk title, by that strange rule that dictates changes is"Love and Kishkes." Very odd.Format: Hardcover (I believe it should have a dust jacket, mine doesn’t have one though I’m not sure the first edition came with one or not. Yes it did. I saw it in Kitchen Arts, but didn’t bother to look at the price. It’s a pastelly semi-abstract design. (If I ever buy a hardcover I don’t require this cover. I’ll make my own cover or adapt the original. I’m a reader not an investor collector.) Kitchen Arts is an Upper East Side store with only cookbooks, with Upper East Side Manhattan prices. The owner gets interviewed by the NYT etc. on cookbook subjects.There was a follow up about the same size “Mazel Tov Y’All”American Jewish Southern Baking. Almost as good.This book is not unlike a few other books published in the 1940s,non-encyclopedic memoirs or the like with a light often humoroustone, e.g. Clementine in the Kitchen (an editor’s French cook who came with them back to America — too French for me) and Ernst Mundt’s Birth of a Cook. Peg Bracken’s classic took this to anentirely new level.Love and Knishes Jewish Cookbook – Popularity Rating – 2.0I’ve given the cookbook a low popularity rating mainly because it is an unknown.It’s not an unknown, or it wouldn’t have been reprinted. It’sa niche item loved by many.Vintage Jewish cookbooks are not very common as not many were published. What you do see a lot of are vintage Jewish community/fundraising cookbooks. This is not one of those books.The ones I’ve seen recalled are 1. London and Kahn Bishov The Complete American Jewish Cookbook, originally published in the early 1950s, with a 1971 reprint and a 1989 almost-too-big paperback (which is the one I own) Typical Ashkenazi Americanized fare.The Bar-David Israeli cookbook of the 1960s. The 1970s must have seen a few, what with the “Jewish Catalog” coming out (Big paperback somewhat modelled on the Whole Earth Catalog) but I haven’t learned of them.What you do see a lot of are vintage Jewish community/fundraising cookbooks.It’s a major headache giving someone a Jewish cookbook. Someof the famous recent ones are blatanty non-kosher. It’s muchsafer to give the latest non-profit endeavor from a kashruthobservant synagogue.There’s a lot of newer ones that are in line with the rules on kashrut, I see them advertised in the Jewish papers and sometimes on sale in the delis. They often have that " Shiny New Cookbook that Looks like All The OtherShiny New Cookbooks" look that’s so prevalent now.That said, I liked what I saw of the Abigael’s cookbook. JeffNathan must have been the author. I actually remember thinking"I might try that" so I should find it and look again. (Abigael’sis a non-fast-food kosher restaurant on Broadway in Midtown Manhattan)There was another from the 1990s, a not very big family memoirby someone named Hirsch called “Our Food” that was nice, but I didn’t buy it either. The recipes were adapted to be lower fat I think.

My 1956 edition does have a dust jacket. Under the jacket it has the same image as the one you posted. I paid $18 for it recently.

Post a comment

Note: comments are moderated before appearing here.

« Previous: Charosis Recipe | Back to Cookbook Collecting and Reviews articles | Next: Towns, Trails & Special Times - Marlboro Cookbook Review - Collectibility »

Secure Online Ordering

© 2012 Cookbook Village. All Rights Reserved. All prices USD.