Cookbook Collecting and Reviews

A Cookbook Village blog written for cookbook collectors and curious cooks. Find out all about collecting cookbooks: used and vintage; reviews and values; recipes and best books to buy for investment.



COOKBOOK COLLECTING




RECIPES




TOP CHEF SIGNATURES




COOKBOOK COLLECTIBILITY REVIEWS




COOKBOOK CHECKLISTS




Betty Crocker's Picture Cook Book Review - Collectibility

Betty Crocker's Picture Book Cover

Betty Crocker's Picture Cookbook is a classic cookbook. Of the many Betty Crocker cookbooks published over time, there are actually three with some real collectibility or investment value.  

Betty Crocker's Picture Cookbook (first published in 1950) with the red background cover and white illustrations. 

Betty Crocker Cook Book often referred to as "the Betty Crocker Red Pie Cookbook" because of its red cover showing a pie shaped montage of photos (first published in 1969).

Betty Crocker's New Picture Cookbook (first published in 1961) with a Mondrian style pink, yellow, white and blue cover). This is the most valuable and sought after of the three.

I have been lucky enough to have owned all of these books since my wife and I began collecting. The below ratings are for the first one above--Betty Crocker's Picture Cookbook. It is now available in a reproduction version just like the original so take care if you are collecting to purchase a first edition from 1950, a first printing is best. Make sure you look for it with the spelling Cook Book and also Cookbook as one word even though incorrect. People tend to use both spellings for this book.

Though this book is more valuable than the Betty Crocker's "Red Pie" Cookbook, the "Red Pie" is my favorite of the bunch. It has decent color photos of all the recipes, whereas the ones with "Picture" in the title have either just illustrations with a few photos or lousy quality photos. Personally, I love photos in my cookbooks--mainly because my wife and I collect more than we actually cook. I'd love to get some feedback on recipes that people enjoy from this book. Please feel free to post comments.

Cookbook Title: Betty Crocker's Picture Cook Book
Authors:
N/A
Publisher: General Mills
Copyright: 1950, First Edition
Format: Hardcover with red background and white illustrations
Specialization Categories: Classic Cookbooks, Vintage Cookbooks
Average Price: $30 ($50 for a First edition, First printing)
Noted Recipes: Vanilla Souffle, Curried Pork Chops with Apricots, Southern Chicken Upside-Down Dinner, Boston Baked Beans, Butterscotch Pie

COOKBOOK COLLECTIBILITY RATINGS RATINGS EXPLAINED

Availability: 4.5
Popularity: 8.0
Investment Outlook: 6.0
-------------------------------------
Final Collectibility Factor: 6.17

Betty Crocker's Picture Cook Book Availability Rating - 4.5
This cookbook is quite easy to find on book seller and auction sites--usually 25+ copies at any given time available. It tends to be much more difficult to find in a retail outlet or garage sale. Auctions usually show in excess of a handful of bidders, many times more. Still, it is continually available online so don't rush to get a copy that is in poor condition if you are truly purchasing for a collection vs. a nice recipe book.

Betty Crocker's Picture Cook Book Popularity Rating - 8.0
Betty Crocker's Picture Cook Book is certainly one of the top vintage cookbooks in terms of popularity. The book remains a constant top seller online--even the reproductions. The most popular book of the three I mention is actually Betty Crocker's New Picture Cook Book which was published eleven years later.

Betty Crocker's Picture Cook Book Investment Outlook - 6.0
The price for this book fluctuates and a lot is dependent upon condition. It does not seem to go up in value over a short-term time period but the book today is exponentially worth a lot more than when originally published. It continually sells at a higher price than the majority of used cookbooks and sometimes reaches up over the $50-$60 range if a first printing in pristine condition. The book is a good investment in terms of owning something that won't depreciate but it will likely be a decade before the book sees any real gain in value.

Betty Crocker's Picture Cook Book Final Collectibility Factor Rating - 6.17
After over 50 years, this cookbook remains a top book for collectors. It is not particularly rare or hard-to-find, but after a long time period, may see an increase in value. The book is a really nice cookbook, loaded with great recipes. You can't really lose, unless you pay a premium for a poor condition or late printing or reproduction of the book. If you can get this book in the $25-$30 range in nice shape--grab it

Comments

I inherited the 1961 cookbook, minus a few pages, from my mother long before I learned to cook, but I cut it up as part of a harebrained project I didn’t even finish. I would love to have another copy, but at this price? In these times? Maybe I’ll put it on my Christmas wish list.

My father was a wholesale grocer in California. I have a “Special Limited Edition” Betty Crocker Cookbook that was presented to my mother at a grocers’ convention in San Francisco in 1950. It is inscribed to my mother and signed by “Betty Crocker,” whom we met at the convention. Boards are blue with red and yellow lettering, and yellow and red flowery scrolling covering front cover. Has matching, hardcover solid blue (no flowers) jacket that book slides into. Jacket has considerable wear. This is the Hardcover Bound book; it is not a ring binder. Boards are clean, brightly colored and tightly bound but there is wear to corners/edges of boards/spine. Pages are clean, unmarked, bright, tightly bound, and most are sharp cornered while some have bent up a bit. I believe this to be a very scarce edition and am trying to establish a value. Can you help me out?

Hi K9Senora,I’ve seen listing for what sounds like the same special edition (but only once or twice). It is usually listed as Scarce and lists from $65-$250 though most are in the $65 range. Cookbook prices seem to be valued somewhat lower since the economic downturn. Hold onto it until prices come up again as it could definitely go in a much higher range. I don’t have much more information. Usually you see only about a handful of these special editions listed on book sites. Best, Ruben

I have a first edition, first printing,(published by General Mills with no mention of McGraw). The inside leaf says " to the Home Economics Department of American Molasses Company with best wishes of The Betty Crocker Staff. Do you think this inscription adds to the value of my Cookbook?

Hi. I have not come across one from the staff—I’ve seen them listed with a signature from one editor or signed as the fictional Betty Crocker presented to an book owner by General Mills. Those are also not very common. I’ve seen them selling in the $60-$65 range. Your book is likely similar though may go for a bit more since it is more authentic, less mainstream then the ones I mention above. I don’t believe it would go over $70 — the first printings are $50 at the high end. It is possible though at auction to get top dollar with your signature. Show photos of the signature page if you do.

Post a comment

Note: comments are moderated before appearing here.

« Previous: Charosis Recipe | Back to Cookbook Collecting and Reviews articles

Secure Online Ordering

© 2012 Cookbook Village. All Rights Reserved. All prices USD.